“The MSU has no legitimacy to govern us” — protestors rally in MUSC

Sasha Dhesi
January 30, 2019
This article was published more than 2 years ago.
Est. Reading Time: 3 minutes
Photos by Sasha Dhesi

Stationed in front of Union Market, student activists put on a demonstration, rallying against the recent changes to the Ontario Student Assistance Program and the legitimacy of the McMaster Students Union.

At around 1:30 p.m. on Jan. 30, protestors gathered in the McMaster University Student Centre. Their protest began on the north side of the first floor of MUSC and then moved to the MSU office.

The group identifies themselves as the Hamilton Student Mobilization Network. HSMN is also the group running the rally against the OSAP cuts occurring on Feb. 1 in Gore Park. In addition to their speech, protestors handed out flyers promoting their Friday protest.

“The provincial government has failed to detail how students will pay for this purported ‘10 per cent decrease’ with inflation and rising debt, and how it endangers university workers without the security of tenure or status,” one protestor said. “The changes undermine student self-governance, destabilize important campus services and deeply impact the accessibility of post-secondary education for current and incoming students.”

In front of UM, the protestors also questioned the priorities of the student union.

“The MSU alleges that it is an advocacy body. But our access to education has been treated as a bureaucratic jungle gym for aspiring government officials to play on — from photo-ops with Doug Ford, to convoluted statements, to superficial consultations, the MSU would rather maintain their image than meaningfully address student issues,” said one protestor.

The protestors also spoke out against the MSU’s ability to maintain democracy. In particular, they focused on the MSU’s lack of movement on multiple motions passed at yearly General Assemblies.

The GA is considered the highest form of democracy in the union and its motions, when the GA meet quorum, are considered binding on the MSU. Quorum, for an MSU GA, means three per cent of the union's membership was in attendance.

Protestors pointed to the MSU’s failure to apply boycott, disinvestment and sanctions against Israel, following a March 2015 ruling at the GA, a meeting which met quorum. They also brought up the continued employment of McMaster head of security and services Glenn DeCaire. During the 2016 GA, students voted in favour of a motion tasking the MSU to lobby for his removal.

Following a demonstration in front of UM, protestors moved to the second floor and continued their protest in the MSU office.

While there, they alleged that Michael Wooder, MSU director of marketing and communications, and John McGowan, MSU general manager, exert undue influence on the direction of the student union.

“The MSU states that McGowan and Wooder are non-voting members. In practice, they manipulate the board of directors to do as they please,” reads a part of the HSMN’s statement. “They deliberately refocus the priorities of this organization through ‘advice’ and ‘support’. They are the only two employees without readily available job descriptions on the MSU website.”

At this time, the MSU has not responded to these allegations.

The HSMN also dropped a banner overlooking the MUSC Atrium. It reads, "The MSU would rather look good than do good," in the style of the McMaster "Brighter World" campaign. The bottom of their banner, however, reads, "Whiter World."

UPDATE: Jan. 30, 3:52 p.m.

MSU president Ikram Farah offered a statement in response to the protest, stating her continued work to challenge the OSAP cuts.

“Students across the province are very upset with the proposed changes to OSAP. The reduction of grant support will undoubtedly lead to an increased debt load for most students," a part of her statement reads. "I share that frustration and I bring it with me as the MSU meets with government officials, opposition members, university administrators and the media. Students have every right to speak their mind and I wholeheartedly support their action to do so. I will continue speaking of the dismay we feel to the government that is decreasing access and affordability to post-secondary education.”

UPDATE: Jan. 30, 4:01 p.m.

The McMaster University Academic Librarians' Association released addressed to Premier Doug Ford against the OSAP cuts and in solidarity with the HSMN.

[thesil_related_posts_sc]Related Posts[/thesil_related_posts_sc]


  • Sasha Dhesi

    Sasha Dhesi is the Managing Editor for Volume 89. A fourth year Justice, Political Philosophy and Law student and Sil lifer, she just wants everyone to have a good time.

Subscribe to our Mailing List

© 2023 The Silhouette. All Rights Reserved. McMaster University's Student Newspaper.